CompetencyWorks is an online resource dedicated to providing information and knowledge about competency education in the K-12 education system. Drawing on lessons learned by innovators and early adopters, CompetencyWorks shares original research, knowledge and a variety of perspectives through an informative blog with practitioner knowledge, policy advancements, papers on emerging issues and a wiki with resources curated from across the field. CompetencyWorks also offers a blog on competency education in higher education so that the sectors can learn from each other and begin to align systems across K-12, higher education and the workplace.

a project of

inacol logo

ACTIONS – Ideas and Strategies for District Leaders

February 18, 2019 by

This is the ninth post in a series that aims to make concepts, themes, and strategies described in Moving Toward Mastery: Growing, Developing, and Sustaining Educators for Competency-Based Education accessible and transferable. Links to the other articles in the series are at the end of this post.

I spent years in a district leadership role trying to help schools navigate the shift toward personalized, competency-based education. One of the the many things I learned during this time was that in order to help schools innovate, I also had to help central office innovate. Specifically, I had to think differently—first for myself, and then for others—about the roles of central office in navigating and sustaining innovation.

In my experience, being called “someone from the district” by someone in a school could carry any number of connotations: someone who made rules, someone who added to teachers’ plates, someone who didn’t get what things were really like in a classroom. Now, this wasn’t one hundred percent true for me, and it’s certainly not one hundred percent true in every district. Still, I share this experience because I think it reflects a concern we have all seen, felt, or experienced at some point: that central office and schools are not always on the same page about how to approach innovation, or how to help teachers help kids.

However—and this is a BIG however—there are lots and lots of examples that prove this perception wrong. More specifically, there are lots and lots of examples of district leaders who play very different roles in orienting, enabling, and supporting learning and teaching on the ground. This is one of  big ideas I want to get across in Moving Toward Mastery: that district leaders can play powerful roles in creating the conditions where teachers can learn and grow so that students can learn and grow. Toward the end of the report I describe the leverage that district leaders have in their roles (page 68). But, I stop short of describing specific actions they can take. This post picks up where the paper left off, offering three big ideas and ten action ideas for district leaders who are trying to grow, develop, and sustain educators for competency-based education.

THREE BIG IDEAS

Let’s start with three framing ideas about the roles district leaders can play in the shift toward personalized, competency-based education.

Districts can orient. The shift toward personalized, competency-based education is a massive one. A key role for district leadership is articulating and modeling a shared vision for change. While it is vital that teachers, leaders, and communities shape this vision, it is incumbent upon district leaders to hold the vision at the forefront. Concretely, this means helping teachers, students, and communities understand what the vision means for them, what they are being asked to do, and what supports are available to them. District leaders share the helm while constantly orienting and guiding the ship.

Districts can enable. In her work “Implementing competency education in K–12 systems: Insights from local leaders,” Chris Sturgis writes, “top-down approaches undermine any efforts to create an empowered staff who will take responsibility for ensuring students are learning. [And] when employees look to the next level up to answer questions and resolve issues, it undermines the culture of learning and is a lost opportunity for building problem-solving capacity within the organization.” Chris is communicating a vital message for district leaders: navigating the shift to personalized, competency-based education requires enabling leadership at all levels. One of the most important things district leaders can do is to cultivate an environment in which teachers and school leaders have the clarity, autonomy, and support to try new things, learn, and make decisions that are best for kids.

I would only add one thing to Chris’s important words: it is important to check your espoused culture against your lived culture. I have known well-intentioned leaders who try to create (and believe they are creating) a culture of empowerment, but whose staff and communities still experience spoken or unspoken set of pressures that tip the scales toward compliance. Unintended barriers, outdated policies, and mixed messages can keep a culture of compliance in place even when leaders are trying diligently to cultivate the opposite.

Districts can support. In his publication Bridging the Gap Between Standards and Achievement: The Imperative for Professional Development in Education, Richard Elmore writes about a concept called “reciprocal accountability.” While there are several dimensions to this concept, here’s one I think is vital: “For every increment of performance I demand from you, I have an equal responsibility to provide you with the capacity to meet that expectation.” Districts undergoing the shift toward personalized, competency-based education will inevitably ask their teachers to make significant shifts in their mindsets, knowledge, skills, and day-to-day actions and routines. Doing this effectively requires providing ample and aligned supports: time to learn, resources to learn, systems that support learning, and communities of practice in which learning is possible. See the earlier post on learning-centered practice for ideas about what this can look like, and where to get started.

TEN DISTRICT LEADER ACTIONS


Get Started

  • Engage your community to create a vision. Convene stakeholders from across your district, ensuring that you include voices that have been historically marginalized or excluded. With diverse perspectives at the table, conduct a landscape assessment of current practice. How are teachers learning and growing? What impact does this have for student learning? What’s working? What’s not? What aspects of professional practice are in or out of alignment with personalized, competency-based education? Based on this assessment, articulate a clear and compelling vision. When all students are learning and achieving at high levels, what will teaching look like?
  • Chart a roadmap. Having an idea about where you want to go is a vital foundation for change. Knowing how to get there is the next step. After setting a vision with your community, create a roadmap for change. What does it look like to get started, move forward, and then sustain comprehensive change? Mistakes and surprises are inevitable. What information will you look at to know what is working and what is not? How will you learn as you go and adjust course? Who do you need to engage along the way?

Create Cultures of Empowerment, Learning, and Growth

  • Empower schools. Articulate a vision for empowerment. Before deciding what’s “tight and loose,” or which decisions lie with which leaders at which levels, define what it means to be a system of empowered schools. What is the purpose of empowerment? How does empowerment serve students, teachers, and leaders? What conditions are necessary to make empowerment work well? With clarity about this vision, leaders can then enact policies and create systems that strategically distribute leadership and decision-making to schools.
  • Address barriers to empowerment. Often, empowerment on paper does not equal empowerment in practice. Education Resource Strategies and the Center for Collaborative Education published a report for the Boston Public Schools detailing the promise and the many challenges of enabling empowerment in practice. This may be a helpful resource for leaders wanting clarity on the types of competing priorities, unintended barriers, and capacity gaps that can inhibit empowerment.
  • Redesign evaluation for continuous improvement. Creating a culture of continuous improvement is key for personalized, competency-based education. Assessment and evaluation are critical drivers of continuous improvement: meaningful systems of student assessment, teacher evaluation, and school quality assessment create conditions in which students, teachers, and leaders can constantly learn and improve. There is a lot that goes into creating such systems. Check out iNACOL’s blog on continuous improvement and brief on assessment for two helpful starting points.

Cultivate Conditions and Systems for Adult Learning

  • Define teacher competencies and a pedagogical framework. Designing a system of professional learning starts with getting clear about what teachers need to know and be able to do in a personalized, competency-based system. More specifically, it starts with getting clear about the outcomes that are expected for students, the types of learning experiences and environments that will support those outcomes, and then what teachers need to know, believe, and be able do do in order to create those experiences and environments. Check out pages 15 through 18 in Moving Toward Mastery for guidance on how to get started.
  • Articulate competency-based professional learning pathways. In competency-based systems, students advance along personalized learning pathways. The same must be true for teachers. Instead of assuming that teachers will move in lockstep through their professional learning and along uniform trajectories of professional growth and advancement, competency-based systems articulate personalized, competency-based professional pathways for teachers. What does this mean? It means teachers can follow personally meaningful learning paths. It means they demonstrate their learning as they grow. And, it means they have opportunities to differentiate and specialize in their roles as they advance. Micro-credentials can be very powerful levers for this type of change. Check out this micro-credentials implementation roadmap from Digital Promise.
  • Align learning experiences. A key step in creating conditions for adult learning is figuring out how to help teachers experience personalized, student-centered learning so that they can create those same experiences for students. This shifts a district leader’s purpose from “ensuring all teachers know what personalized, student-centered learning is” to “helping schools create the conditions in which teachers can cultivate personalized, student-centered learning.” The answer to this question might include investing in coaching, communities of practice, and anywhere-anytime learning technologies. And often, it will mean reallocating resources like time, technology, and people.

Mitigate Individual and Institutional Bias

  • Promote diversity and inclusion. A diverse and representative teaching force helps all learners achieve personal and academic success, especially learners of color. This matters in the shift to competency-based education because at its core, competency-based education is about increasing equity. District leaders can play important roles in deepening equity-focused practice by hiring, supporting, and retaining educators who reflect their students, and creating inclusive professional cultures for all educators and staff. See page 26 of Moving Toward Mastery for ideas about where to get started.
  • Prioritize culturally responsive practice. Getting to equity involves increasing cultural responsiveness. Certainly this is true in the classroom, and district leaders can play important roles in prioritizing and supporting professional learning that builds teachers’ capacities as culturally competent practitioners. It is also vital to build this capacity in central office. Supervisors, curriculum developers, budget analysts, professional coaches—all of these roles need to understand what culturally relevant practice looks like in the classroom, and in their own positions. For district leaders, helping shift learning and teaching toward cultural relevance means building capacity at all levels.

Read the entire series:

  1. Introducing Moving Toward Mastery
  2. Entry Points: Moving Toward Equity-Oriented Practice
  3. Voices: Developing Teacher Mindsets
  4. Entry Points: Moving Toward Learner-Centered Practice
  5. Actions: Ideas and Strategies for School Leaders
  6. Voices – Lisa Simms on Leading and Sustaining Innovation
  7. Entry Points – First Steps Toward a Lifelong Profession
  8. Voices – Jennifer Kabaker on Changing the Narrative and Recruiting Lifelong Educators

About the Author

Katherine Casey is Founder and Principal of Katherine Casey Consulting, an independent organization focused on innovation, personalized and competency-based school design, and research and development. Katherine was a founding Director of the Imaginarium Innovation Lab in Denver Public Schools, supporting a portfolio of almost 30 schools across Denver and spearheading the Lab’s research and development activity. Katherine was a founding design team member at the Denver School of Innovation and Sustainable Design, Denver’s first competency-based high school. Prior to her time in Denver, Katherine worked in leadership development, philanthropy, public affairs and higher education. She received her BA from Stanford University and her Doctorate in Education Leadership from Harvard University.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

VOICES – Jennifer Kabaker on Changing the Narrative and Recruiting Lifelong Educators

February 15, 2019 by

This is the eighth post in a ten-part series that aims to make concepts, themes, and strategies described in the Moving Toward Mastery: Growing, Developing, and Sustaining Educators for Competency-Based Education report accessible and transferable. Links to the other articles in the series are at the end of this post.

How can we recruit and retain lifelong educators who will learn, improve, and lead over the course of their careers? This of course is a question for the entire field of education, not just for competency-based education. But I think it is a particularly important question for competency-based districts and schools to grapple with because becoming a competency-based educator is a continuous process of personal mastery. You don’t become masterful overnight; it takes time.

Moving Toward Mastery touches on this question in two sections: diversifying pathways into the profession and diversifying pathways through the profession. Essentially, the paper says that states, districts, and schools share responsibility for (1) creating recruitment, preparation, and placement pathways that meet teacher workforce needs and ensure diversity; (2) connecting these early stages of a teacher’s professional pathway to their ongoing learning, development, and advancement; and (3) creating opportunities for teachers to grow and lead in their careers so that they stay in the teaching profession.

These ideas can seem far away and unreachable. To bring them closer into view, I thought it would be useful to highlight a leader and organization working to create pathways into teaching, and crafting a narrative about teaching as a lifelong profession. This post highlights the voice and work of Jennifer Kabaker and the team at TEACH. (more…)

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

It’s Time to Submit Proposals to the iNACOL Symposium

February 13, 2019 by

The iNACOL Symposium will be held on October 28-31, 2019 at the Palm Springs Convention Center in Palm Springs, California.

iNACOL is now accepting Requests for Presentation Proposals to present at the iNACOL Symposium, held at the Palm Springs Convention Center in Palm Springs, California on October 28-31, 2019. This year’s theme is: Shining a Light on the Future of Learning. iNACOL’s annual conference is the premier learning conference for those driving the transformation of education systems and accelerating the advancement of breakthrough policies and practices to ensure high-quality learning for all. Experts, practitioners, educators, policymakers, researchers and innovators gather and work to transform education.

To access the RFP and submit your proposal to present, please click hereThe deadline for submitting presentation proposals is Friday, March 8, 2019 at 11:59 p.m. ET. You can download the RFP questions in advance by clicking this link. The iNACOL Program Committee will notify applicants of proposal status no later than Monday, May 6, 2019. (more…)

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

In Real Life: How do CBE systems manage differences in pace?

February 11, 2019 by

Mallory Haar, English as a New Language Teacher, Casco Bay High School, ME.

This article is the sixth in a nine-part “In Real Life” series based on the complex, fundamental questions that practitioners in competency-based systems grapple with “in real life.” Links to the other posts can be found at the end of this article.

Competency-based education (CBE) systems meet students where they are and support them to master a pre-defined set of learning targets at their own pace. Managing a group of learners who are at different places in their learning might seem doable if their paces are similar, but what about students who deviate widely from the class norm or “teacher pace”? Are there limits to how quickly or slowly students are allowed to move through the system?

To better understand how competency-based systems reckon with these questions, I sat down with Mallory Haar, who teaches English as a New Language and English Literature at Casco Bay High School in Portland, Maine.

(more…)

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

What’s New in K-12 Competency-Based Education?

February 8, 2019 by

What's New Image

RESOURCES

  • iNACOL just released our 2019 State Policy Priorities and 2019 Federal Policy Priorities. These briefs provide a long-range vision of reforms needed to create personalized, competency-based learning environments to ensure that all students develop the knowledge, skills, and dispositions they will need to achieve success and advance society.
  • In How to Design a Competency-Based Assessment, Eric Hudson, the Director of Learning and Teaching at Global Online Academy, provides an overview of four main steps: articulating competencies, developing evidence, building student-friendly rubrics, and creating learning experiences – with extensive links to more detailed information.
  • In Designing Advisory Systems: Innovative Approaches from High Schools, Springpoint provides five case studies of advisory systems that aim to build community, create a safe environment, and ensure that every student has a trusted adult invested in their success. Each school has a different approach to advisory, customized to its students and context, so the report provides a variety of helpful models and program elements.

(more…)

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

In Real Life: How feedback loops and student supports help ensure learning is deep, ongoing, and integrated.

February 6, 2019 by

Elizabeth Cardine, Lead Teacher and Advisor, MC2 Schools, NH

This article is the fifth in a nine-part “In Real Life” series based on the complex, fundamental questions that practitioners in competency-based systems grapple with “in real life.” Links to the other posts can be found at the end of this article.

Competency-based education (CBE) systems define competencies and learning progressions to make learning expectations more transparent and accessible to students; but such transparency can be prone to the unintended consequence of creating a “check the box” mentality that compromises depth and relevance.

To better understand how competency-based systems balance the desire for transparency with the need for depth, I sat down with Elizabeth Cardine, Lead Teacher and Advisor at Making Community Connections (MC2) Charter Schools in New Hampshire.

(more…)

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

ENTRY POINTS – First Steps Toward a Lifelong Profession

February 4, 2019 by

This is the seventh post in a ten-part series that aims to make concepts, themes, and strategies described in the Moving Toward Mastery: Growing, Developing, and Sustaining Educators for Competency-Based Education report accessible and transferable. Links to the other articles in the series are at the end of this post.

“A lifelong profession engages, develops and sustains educators over the course of their careers. Educators are supported and trusted as respected members of a respected profession. They are meaningfully and adequately prepared for the roles they will take on, they have opportunity to grow and specialize in their careers, and they are evaluated in ways that support improvement and promote advancement.” – Moving Toward Mastery, p. 51

Becoming a masterful educator does not happen overnight, or in a year, or in two. It is a continuous process of learning and growth. As Peter Senge wrote, “personal mastery is not something you possess. It is a process. It is a lifelong discipline.” Getting to equity for our students and families means finding, developing, and keeping exceptional people in the classroom.

Moving Toward Mastery paints a picture of teaching as a “lifelong” profession. But admittedly, of all the ideas in the paper, “lifelong” can seem the most abstract. Of course we want teachers to have powerful experiences in their preparation programs, to be able to learn and grow as educators, to be evaluated in fair and meaningful ways, and to stay in the profession while they develop mastery. But the changes needed to bring about these conditions can seem far away, especially for people working in schools or districts.

(more…)

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

VOICES – Lisa Simms on Leading and Sustaining Innovation

February 1, 2019 by

This is the sixth post in a ten-part series that aims to make concepts, themes, and strategies described in the Moving Toward Mastery: Growing, Developing, and Sustaining Educators for Competency-Based Education report accessible and transferable. Links to the other articles in the series are at the end of this post.

“Competency-based districts and schools are innovative at their core. Educators are at the forefront of innovation, leading the way as they test and share new practices. But, it is a mistake to think about innovators as lone actors or rogue agents of change. Innovators are collaborative practitioners focused on trying, testing and growing new ideas that improve student learning and support school improvement.” – Moving Toward Mastery, p. 48

“Creating a culture of innovation” gets talked about a lot in competency-based education. Almost everyone can agree that implementing dramatic changes in education at all levels requires that everyone, from students to superintendents to state leaders, be willing and able to try, test, and refine new ways of working. What’s sometimes harder to understand is how a “culture of innovation” actually happens. As I listen to teachers and leaders reflect on challenges in their work and as I reflect on my own leadership in the field, here are some questions that come to mind for which there are no easy or clear answers:

How do leaders actually create environments in which people can innovate well? How can leaders balance the need for innovation with the pressures for performance? In what ways does innovation look different (and require different leadership and structures and activities) in early-stage endeavors compared to late-stage ones? What does it look like to sustain innovation over time?

To help answer these questions, I spoke with Lisa Simms. Lisa is a founding design team member and current principal at Denver School of Innovation and Sustainable Design. DSISD opened its doors in fall of 2015, offering competency-based and project-based learning in early college pathways. In this post, Lisa reflects on what it means to lead for innovation in the fourth year of a new competency-based high school: how she supports teachers to innovate and stay the course as they prepare to graduate their founding class. (more…)

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

In Real Life: How can CBE systems ensure learning is deep, ongoing, and integrated?

January 30, 2019 by

This article is the fourth in a nine-part “In Real Life” series based on the complex, fundamental questions that practitioners in competency-based systems grapple with “in real life.” Links to the other posts can be found at the end of this article.

Long before she had GPS on her mobile phone, my mother would navigate for our family road trips using turn-by-turn directions printed out from the American Automobile Association. While my father drove, she would call out the next set of turns so that he always knew where he was headed and what to do when he got there.

In much the same way, growing numbers of educators across the country are building competency-based systems designed to help students navigate the learning journey ahead. Such systems define learning targets or competencies that serve as guideposts for what students should know and be able to do as they progress through their learning. Many systems also sequence competencies (although not always linearly) into instructional learning progressions and utilize technology to display students’ progress in real time.

The goal is transparency: students need not wonder what is expected of them, but instead have a clear roadmap for the knowledge, skills, and mindsets they are expected to master next.

At the same time, some question whether such transparency has a downside of reducing learning to a shallow check-list of tasks that students race through to complete. After all, if we improve highway visibility, won’t cars be prone to speeding? (more…)

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Webinar on Submitting Your Proposal to Present at iNACOL Symposium 2019 (February 4, 3:00 p.m. ET)

January 29, 2019 by

iNACOL WebinarInterested in presenting at the 2019 Symposium in Palm Springs, CA? Please join iNACOL for a webinar focused on developing session topics and presentations that will stand out in the upcoming Request for Proposal (RFP) process, on February 4 from 3:00-4:00 p.m. Eastern Time.

We also have tips to help you generate meaningful collaboration, foster engagement, and effectively share knowledge during your session.

You can register for the webinar here. The presenters are Bruce Friend, iNACOL Chief Operating Officer, and Natalie Abel Slocum, iNACOL Strategic Partnerships Director.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
WordPress SEO fine-tune by Meta SEO Pack from Poradnik Webmastera